Goodness vs Givebutter

Your donors came to support your mission, so that’s all your checkout asks of them. Behind every gift, Goodness gives your team a full donor CRM, an AI teammate, and reporting built to grow what you raise, for one clear platform fee.

See them side by side
The short version

Why teams choose
Goodness over Givebutter.

Your donors never see a tip request.

Givebutter’s free plan depends on tips donors add at checkout. With tips turned off, Givebutter charges a 3% platform fee plus processing. Goodness has no tip option: your plan sets one platform fee, and donors can choose to cover card processing.

AI that does the work.

Sidekick finds donors, records gifts, builds events and reports, and drafts follow-ups from one conversation. A person approves anything sensitive, such as a refund or an email send.

Event building and drafting on Growth and Scale

Know who to call next.

Nightly engagement scores, churn-risk and upgrade signals, and wealth research from public filings and property records show your team where a personal conversation belongs.

Wealth research on Growth and Scale

Reporting your board will read.

Ask for a report in plain English, track goals against even pace for the year, and open the gifts behind any chart. Schedule results to arrive by email.

Keep every grant on schedule.

Give each step a deadline and each grant an owner. Your team’s next step shows on the owner’s task list, and a follow-up appears when a funder is late.

Growth and Scale

Show your board where to help.

Set each board member’s fundraising goal. Their own page shows gifts toward it from the prospects they add, plus 3 to 5 AI-suggested introductions, each with a reason.

Growth and Scale
At a glance

Side by side.

Only what each company publishes. Where Givebutter’s pages don’t say, we don’t guess.

Goodness and Givebutter compared
GoodnessGivebutter
How it’s fundedYour plan and its platform feeOptional donor tips, or a 3% fee with tips off
Asks donors to tipNeverYes, optional for donors
How each one charges

Two pricing models.

Goodness

  • Starter$0 a month · 3%
  • Growth$299 a month · 2%
  • Scale$599 a month · 1%

Unlimited contacts on every plan, billed monthly. Donors can cover card processing, and they’re never asked to tip.

See Goodness pricing

Givebutter

  • Free plan, funded by optional tips that donors add at checkout.
  • With tips off: a 3% platform fee, plus 2.9% + 30¢ card processing.
  • Givebutter Plus adds features from $29 a month, priced by contact count.

From Givebutter’s public pricing on November 17, 2026.

Beyond the checkout

Built for what happens after the gift.

A checkout records the gift. Goodness gives your team what it needs to grow the relationship behind it.

  • One donor record

    Gifts, events, households, pledges, notes, and tasks on one timeline your whole team works from.

  • Galas, end to end

    Tables and seating, sponsorships, live giving screens, auctions, and check-in for the whole night.

    Tables, seating, and live screens on Growth and Scale
  • Thank-yous that fit the gift

    Acknowledgment tiers set the thank-you each gift size earns, from an email with the receipt to a call or a letter, and turn each one into a task. Year-end statements run in one batch.

Moving from Givebutter

Bring your history with you.

Goodness recognizes Givebutter exports of contacts, companies, and transactions, and can also sync through Givebutter’s API. Check the mapping, preview the records, then import.

Plan your move to Goodness
  1. 01ExportYour donors, gifts, and history.
  2. 02Map and previewMatch columns and check every record.
  3. 03Import and goNothing is written until you confirm.
A few useful answers

Before you ask.

How does Goodness charge without asking for tips?

Goodness Starter has no subscription and a 3% platform fee on payments, without asking donors for tips. Growth and Scale lower the fee to 2% and 1% for a monthly subscription.

Can I keep my Givebutter history?

Yes. Goodness imports Givebutter contacts, companies, and transactions, and keeps them on each donor’s record.

Can I run my next event in Goodness?

Yes. Ticketing, check-in, silent auctions, fund-a-need, and peer-to-peer are part of every plan.

More comparisons

We compared Goodness with Givebutter using Givebutter’s public website on November 17, 2026. Features and prices change, so confirm details with Givebutter. Givebutter is a trademark of its owner, named here only to identify its product.

See what’s possible
for your nonprofit.

Bring your questions. Explore your work in Goodness.